Why is homeschooling illegal

The Opposition case stood. We consistently showed that homeschooling enriches students, that it gives them better — in some cases, the only — education for life and thus ensures social integration. We also showed that society benefits from legal homeschooling and that keeping it legal is principally justified. US refutation was fragmented, seized on details rather than whole ideas, and succumbed to our POIs.

More importantly, our arguments forced Team USA to make a number of concessions. In claiming that parents are responsible, caring, and personally incentivized which sets them apart from public school teachers and enables them to teach better , they assented to our original argument. Secondly, USA at first argued that public schools are the perfect solution; then admitted that they badly need reform.

Thirdly, our POIs revealed that their asserted importance of socialization is caved by their espousal of the TCS in NZ, a symptom of wider failure to provide definitions. In contrast, Team USA had no teamline; only inconsistent logic and faulty fundamentals. As an Orthodox Christian we DO have the right to instill our religious beliefs in our children. We had children partly to preserve the faith. Our Christian faith tells us to be not of this world.

We believe govt should be small and limited and is a necessary evil, not a public good. We believe we live in a fallen world and corrupt society. Both my husband and I hold advanced degrees. We make sure that our children associate with like minded families. If home schooling is going to continue, those children need to be evaluated at least once a year to ensure that they are progressing academically, meeting standards set by the school boards for their regions.

Neither environment is healthy for the children. I homeschool my 2 youngest children and do not regret it one bit. They are vaccinated, and that has nothing to do with homeschool. Some children thrive better in public school or private school. Others thrive better being homeschooled. Socialization is not a problem for homeschoolers. Mine go to a co-op, which is a group of homeschoolers taking classes like a classroom setting.

They are with other children and learning different subjects. For example, I teach both hours our co-op has 2 class times, once a week. Both subjects are STEM classes. One is for 1st through 3rd grade and the other is for 4th through 6th grade. The classes are small — my largest class is 12 children and both of my classes have another mom as a co-teacher.

Not only are they learning but also being socialized — not just someone their own grade, but they learn to respect children that are not their age as well as adults. There are a variety of classes at co-op. Required subjects, electives, and life skills classes such as how to manage money or how to start a business.

As far as not being around different cultures and religions, that is false. There are many different cultures and religious people that homeschool and are with other children of different cultures and religions. Field trips are awesome learning experiences that my kids actually enjoy. Hands on experiments help my children enjoy learning and actually retain what they are learning. Not every child learns the same way. Even when we are not sitting down officially homeschooling, they are still learning every single day.

For example, my children helping me cook dinner teaches them life skills, math, and health. Even going to the grocery store can be turned into a learning experience. They can even learn budgeting by helping with the grocery planning and shopping. Oh, and there is far less bullying with homeschooled children. Again, they learn to respect others.

My children actually get along at home most of the time without fighting and play together usually without issues. No one is perfect, but it has been the right choice for me. My older 2 children were in public school. They are doing ok, but it was difficult at times, especially spending quality time with them. They had hours of homework after school and on weekends. I went to primary school and loved it, i had all the support and help but when it came to secondary it was dreadful!

I had no support from anybody so me and my family decided for me to be home schooled. It was the best option now i can work at my own pace and i am more happier in myself and i am really confident now then i was! I joined a tennis club for home schooled children and i love it! There is a lot of educational places to go and you can get discount! Homeschooling is the best option for me i get a lot more free time and i still meet up with my friends! Its one of the best choices i have ever made!!

I went to public school from preschool all the way through Freshman year of high school. My Sophomore year my parents and I decided to switch over to homeschooling. I can work at my own pace In some classes I take 6 days to learn and take the test on the 7th day, in others I take up to 12 days I can get help from my parents any time of the day and I feel like I have less of a workload less weight on my shoulders. I can still hang out with friends on weekends and Wednesday nights.

The greatest pros for homeschooling is the increasingly abysmal quality of public school. Opponents to homeschooling often criticize fundamentalists as though mainly religious conservatives are behind this rising movement, but in fact, the desire for a quality education for our children which affirms our personal values is a cross-party-cultural shared mission.

In fact, if homeschooling could become available for all citizens through a voucher system, public schools, ….

I was homeschooled so that makes me socially retarted huh? Hey TD! Your children will be socially retarded, Does that not mean anything to you? Are you just expressing the control freak that pushes people to home school their kids? I cannot even begin to address the grammatical errors, let alone the flawed content exhibited here by ignorant anti-homeschoolers.

School has lots of benefits, for lots of children, and a ot of harm for others. Are you willing to gamble with your child?

That was my first thought upon visiting this site. People who have experience with the mature, self motivated, and responsible adults who are turned out into society after being homeschooled do sometimes suspect it. My kids are well mannered, kind, good citizens, law abiding, talented, and dependable. Beyond that they were able to hold intelligent and lengthy conversations with adults or peers from a very young age, impressing people with their grasp of concepts and vocabulary. They are not geniuses.

They were homeschooled by parents who are incentivized to do so expertly and with great care. Do NOT let them take this liberty away. No need to worry about home school rights being taken from people like this. You think these same people will allow drug testing of welfare recipients? Uh, no. In my personal opinion, giving your children the chance to think independently whereas public schools do not is what homeschooling does for children, it gives them a chance to become leaders, form their own ideas and integrate it into society.

The children are told what to think, what the government thinks they should know and are not given a chance to really be able to disagree or argue their thoughts.

This, on top of the fact that public schools have to go at a set pace and children are unable to show their true potential or expand it as they get older which is what I believe is seriously lacking in our society. That is the only thing I could see needing regulated, but to what extent, usually when the government is asked to get involved it ends up being more than they should…but how to know where that line is????

For the part about not being challenged, have you ever heard of things called enriched learning classes of extracurricular activities. Public school provides children with all purpose knowlege so they can decide to do whatever they want, even if that goal changes. I am a retired junior math instructor, loved it, but never did I compare the two. However, homeschooled kids have more extracurricular activities. Thousands of school districts in the U. Just to make things perfectly clear, I am not religious, as a matter of fact, my ONLY belief is in facts, what I can see and touch.

I am an extremely open-minded individual and I intend on teaching my children world religions, so they can choose for themselves and I will support whatever they choose. Now, to make a point, I am protective of my child but not to the point of being overbearing.

I just refuse to let my son go to a school that has a playground open to the public when a known pedophile lives in the same neighborhood as the school and on several occasions I have found the teachers not capable of paying enough attention, my son was hurt, came home with more bruises than could possibly happen on a playground and the only thing he seemed to learn was how to be a bully and be disrespectful to everyone around him.

As far as basic social skills go, my children are involved in numerous extracurricular activities my son is extremely social and active they have no problems being capable of being social without being socially awkward. So who knows what would be best to do about that kind of situation, but banning homeschooling is NOT the solution. My thoughts exactly. More and more the most educated adults are choosing to homeschool.

We have formed cooperatives and classes on our own to fill in educational needs of any variety. It is our right and there are so many of us that unless the government finds a way to override the constitution we will be able to hold onto that right.

Not to mention we are falling globally in education. If you want less safe, lower quality education for your child — you have that right. That stinks. Even badly war ravaged Vietnam is Well said! I believe that children should have to have a qualifying medical condition before homeschooling becomes an option.

People who are home schooled do not know how to act and they are NOT taught to think freely, They simply express the ideas of the parent. People I know who were home schooled have no friends and are looked upon as idiots because of their social retardation. Oh my.

This is so ridiculous. Listen to how you broadbrush a huge swath of people as if you know everything. If you went to public school you were taught what to think. There is a large difference. Debate was encouraged and we never formed opinions for our kids. Being honest, responsible, and productive were cornerstones of what we taught.

My kids have taken different routes — one in the arts and one in law. One is still at home. All three are considered bright, articulate, passionate, and talented by anyone that has met them. The two oldest had a large group of close friends both mainly through their sports who always marveled that the girls were homeschooled.

The middle child went into the public school in her last two years and was ADORED by teachers, classmates, and coaches. As far as anyone knew she was one of them… Except a high achieving honor roll student who somehow managed to be outgoing and funny and a star athlete…. All this and she was homeschooled through the age of Tell me, how many homeschooled adults do you know? Thanks to kids like mine, important things get done and innovation is supported.

They are not indoctrinated but they know what it means to be. Seems to me that people like you are afraid of having people like that amongst you. I failed to include that my older daughter is a gifted dancer who is praised for her skills and inspiring choreography by people in her field.

She is graceful, kind, respectful, and someone that mentors many. How do you know? I personally know hundreds. Ideas of the parents? And who else? Colleges like homeschooled kids. No or little truancy, for the most part they pay their own way and. Drugs, drinks, misuse of electronic devices, bullying, tardiness, and truancy, school lunch scuffles and battles over lunch quality, long lines of cars before and after school, School bus harassment, insidious spats over dress standards, unqualified teachers and staff, over emphasis of sports over academics, homeschooled kids do very well on CLEP and DSST scores, accidents and mischief to and from school.

There may be a few poor quality parents out there, but they ae equaled by poor quality teaching staff or worse yet, poor working conditions. I was in a small school last week that hired 16 new teachers and four new staff. However, the global picture is mixed , with little consistency in legislation and regulation, even across countries within the same region.

A brief scan shows that homeschooling is legal in Australia, New Zealand, and Canada. In the United States, homeschooling is legal in all 50 states and it is estimated that over two million children are currently educated at home, up from ten thousand in the early s. Little information is available on the status of homeschooling in African countries.

South Africa is an exception where homeschooling is expressly permitted under paragraph 51 of the South African Schools Act, The Act requires parents to register their homeschooled children with the provincial department for education. However, many departments for education do not have sufficient capacity to administer such a registration process, leading to a high proportion of homeschooling parents simply not doing so.

This means precise figures for children being homeschooled are not available, but are estimated to be between sixty thousand and one hundred thousand children annually. Across Europe, while homeschooling largely appears to be on the rise , the landscape, in terms of legislation and regulation, is varied. In some countries, such as France , the United Kingdom , Austria, Norway, Denmark, Finland, and Ireland homeschooling is widely accepted as a legitimate alternative to state or private schools.

There are, conversely, a number of European countries where homeschooling is illegal. Under international law, the child is the primary beneficiary of the right to education and education must conform to certain aims.

International law additionally stipulates that states are legally bound to structure their education systems, whether delivered by the state or a private provider, in order to ensure that these requirements are met ICESCR, Article 13; CRC, Articles 28 and Ultimately, what this means is that international law places obligations on states to ensure that children, as rights-holders, are able to enjoy their right to education, and the provision of that education must conform to certain aims and minimum standards.

Similarly, the German education ministry highlights the essential role school-based education plays in the socialisation of children , and the importance of such socialisation to other cultures, religions, and customs in order for every child to grow up to be a well-rounded citizen in an increasingly multicultural society. Indeed, one of the drivers of the creation of human rights law in the aftermath of World War II was a desire to protect the freedoms of religious minorities.

So, although children are the primary beneficiaries of the right to education, international law recognises that children are not fully autonomous rights-holders, and that parents and legal guardians have the right to exercise freedom of religion and conscience, which includes freedom from unnecessary state interference in how they chose to bring up their children International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights [, ICCPR], Article 18 4 ; ICESCR, Article 13 3.

The freedom of non-state actors to establish private schools, although intimately connected with freedom of religion and conscience and a key means to protect it, is a freedom that extends to everyone.

This means that anyone can establish and operate any type of school with certain restrictions, discussed below. Other than religious schools, schools that cater for Indigenous Peoples and minorities, particularly linguistic minorities , are common and are a key means of protecting culture. As are schools that employ alternative pedagogies, for example, self-directed and hands-on learning, and schools that allow children to focus on their passions and non-academic talents, such as the performing arts or sports.

There is a lot of variety when it comes to homeschool laws in Europe. Some countries where it is very popular include the United Kingdom, Poland and France.

Though homeschooling is on the rise in these countries in many countries in Europe homeschooling is still illegal, although countries are legalizing it slowly but surely. Are you wondering in what countries in Europe homeschooling is legal and what the regulations are? Here is Everything you need to know about the homeschool laws in Europe.

Having 44 countries in Europe, laws are very different throughout. Some countries allow homeschooling with no regulations or restrictions, while in other countries homeschooling is completely illegal. Austria: Homeschooling is legal and regulated in Austria, having over 2, homeschoolers in the country. In Austria homeschooling is considered a type of private school. Parents do not need any special qualifications to homeschool their children, but before the beginning of the school year parents need to notify the districts school board.

Azerbaijan: Homeschooling has recently become legal in Azerbaijan. Homeschool parents are required to provide an equal education to what their children would get in conventional school. Homeschool students need to take exams so that they can officially move up each level of education. Belgium: In Belgium education is mandatory for ages 6 to 17, but parents have the option to chose how they want to educate their children. So parents can chose to teach their kids themselves.

Belgium has 3 language communities and there are specific regulations within the regional level. Students must follow guidelines and inspections. Denmark: Homeschooling is legal for all aged students in Denmark and currently growing.

It is up to the parent to choose where their children are schooled. There are mandatory inspection each year for homeschoolers, and inspections are controlled by the local district public school. Estonia: Estonia allows homeschooling under the control of a school. Parents are required to apply to homeschool their child each year at the school their child is enrolled in.

Each homeschool child is required to take regular exams and will be supervised by an authorized school. If students do not pass the exams they are required to return to conventional school.

Finland: Homeschooling is legal and protected by the law in Finland. Parents have the right to homeschool their children, the only obligation to homeschooling in Finland is that students need to meet basic education standards. Written and oral exams are mandatory to make sure students are making progress.

France: Homeschooling is legal and families need to notify their school district of their intent to homeschool each year. Families will also need to send a letter to their mayors office in their region. Once the letters have been sent parents are able to educate their children any way they would like.

Inspections are mandatory and homeschool students may be required to take standardized tests. Ireland: Now being legal, homeschooling is considered one of the fastest growing types of education in Ireland.

Students need to register as a homeschooler with the National Education Welfare Board, the board will then send an inspector to the families home and go through the regulations of registering the student.

Italy: It is legal to homeschool in Italy and the Italian Constitution believes that parents should have a right to educate, support and instruct their children. Parents need to notify their appropriate school authorities about their intent of homeschooling annually. Occasionally parents will also need to demonstrate their financial and technical ability to educate their child at home.

Students need to take annual exams and parents have to create a personal curriculum and a written request for the exam. Homeschooling does not have any requirements for children up to grade 6. Past grade 6 homeschooling is possible for students, but the education has to be formal home education or long distance studies.